Shingle Roof Replacement in Elmwood from $4.50. Architectural at $5.50 to $8.00 a square foot, three-tab cheaper, and the eaves detail that decides both. Free inspection and a written quote.
Low eaves close to a neighbor make the first three feet both the most vulnerable part of the roof and the hardest to work. Ask for the ice barrier coverage as a measurement, because that is where freeze and thaw drives water back up under the courses.
Architectural shingle installs at $5.50 to $8.00 per square foot in New Jersey and three-tab at $4.50 to $6.50. On an average roof that is a few thousand dollars of difference, and it is the clearest case in this trade of a cheaper quote being a lesser roof rather than a better price.



Three-tab installs at $4.50 to $6.50 per square foot in New Jersey and architectural at $5.50 to $8.00. On pre-war housing there is a second variable that matters as much: what the shingle is going onto, because board sheathing and plywood are not the same job. Access is the line to expect, and it is not padding. One route up, one route down for waste, and on a tenanted house a parking arrangement while the dumpster is on the curb. It also makes phasing worse value here than elsewhere, because mobilization is the expensive part.
Freeze and thaw drives water back up under the courses at the eaves, which is what an ice barrier is for. Its coverage is a measurable line on a scope and it is invisible once the roof looks finished.
The correct pattern in the correct zone is what survives a February gust, and it cannot be inspected afterwards. It has to be in writing beforehand.
Two coverings is the practical limit. A roof already at two is a tear-off whatever anybody quotes, so a cheap overlay price on a twice-covered roof is not a price.
Tight frontages are the practical constraint. Material goes up the front and waste comes down the front, so the sidewalk is part of the plan rather than an afterthought -- and on a three-family house with tenants, so is where they park while the work runs.
One is about your building and one is about your covering, and most quotes in this city establish neither.
Slate outlives almost everything fixed to it. Slipped slates usually mean corroded nails; leaks at a valley usually mean a rusted lining. Both are repairs. Replacing an existing slate roof is $20 to $35 per square foot, so the difference between diagnosing that correctly and not runs to tens of thousands.
On asphalt, if the covering away from the leak still lies flat, holds its granules and is not brittle, the roof has life in it and a repair is the right job. A failed flashing or a split upstand is hundreds of dollars and is routinely produced as proof that the whole roof is finished.
Two coverings is the practical ceiling. A roof already at two is a tear-off whatever anybody quotes, and it takes two minutes to check at the rake edge. It is the fastest way to tell whether the quotes in front of you describe the same job.
Tight frontages set the logistics and the logistics set part of the price.
Three tenancies on a tight frontage is the hardest scheduling problem on this site.
Short runs are the Elmwood problem.
Less slate survives here than in the larger-house districts, so when it does appear the profile and size are less likely to be matchable from stock.
Tight sites make phasing worse than it looks, because mobilization is a bigger share of the cost when access is difficult.
The three-unit line runs right through this city.
The largest houses, and where slate survives.
Genuinely mixed eras. A neighbor proves nothing.
Duplexes divided into three, and the traces that leaves.
Flat roofs behind parapets. Access comes first.
Same buildings, a different construction office.
Three-plus units is the default, not the exception.
The questions that come up, before you have to ask.
Architectural on most houses, and the difference is real: $5.50 to $8.00 per square foot against $4.50 to $6.50. It is heavier, handles wind better and lasts longer. Three-tab is defensible on a small simple roof or a building being sold shortly.
Frequently board sheathing rather than plywood, and that changes the job: boards with gaps between them hold a nail differently, and any that have to be made good are a real cost. It is established by looking, not by assuming, and it belongs in the scope.
Because most online figures are national and this is not a national market. New Jersey pricing is $9,500 to $26,000 for an architectural asphalt roof, and a good part of the difference is detailing a warm climate does not need: ice barrier at the eaves, drip edge, and the nailing to survive a February gust.
Two to four days on site for a house, three to five for a three-family building, and one to three weeks for slate -- slate cannot be rushed without breaking material. Weather moves all of them and we will not dry-in a roof we cannot finish. Where a permit applies, the filing and closing inspection are days on top.
No. The inspection is free, the written quote is free, and neither carries an obligation. The survey also answers the unit-count and permit question in writing, which is worth having even if you use somebody else. What we will not do is give you a number at the curb without going up.
Unit count established before anything is priced. New Jersey figures, not a national calculator.